Win Win is about Mike Flaherty (Giamatti), a good man who makes a bad choice and then pays for it when things get complicated. The bad choice comes when he lies to the court to gain the guardianship of Leo, a senior suffering from dementia, for the sole purpose of getting the paycheck that comes with that responsibility. Flaherty's law practice is going under financially, a fact he has kept from his family. The money from the guardianship will allow him to keep the critical bills paid.
The complication comes from the unexpected arrival of Leo's long lost grandson, Kyle, perfectly played by 16-year-old newcomer, Alex Shaffer. Kyle doesn't have a father, and his mother's penchant for abusive substances and boyfriends has finally taken its toll. Flaherty has no choice but to take Kyle in. Flaherty's wife, superbly played by Amy Ryan, is suddenly having to deal with a lot of problems she doesn't understand and didn't create.
Flaherty is also the coach of the local high school wrestling team, which much like his law practice, isn't going anywhere. It's not long before he discovers that Kyle is a genuinely gifted wrestler who can give Flaherty's losing team a real shot at a state title game. With that seemingly impossible goal finally in sight, the web of deception unravels, putting at risk his relationship with Kyle, whom the entire Flaherty family has grown to love.
This is Shaffer's first film. He is an actual high school state wrestling champion and infuses the sports scenes with a strong dose of reality. He is also a convincing actor and someone to watch in the future.
This is a timely story about a man who makes a bad choice under financial pressure and must pay the consequences when he is finally forced to come clean. He gets back on the right path at the end, but that path is a hard one, something this film doesn't shy away from. It's not a Hollywood ending. Flaherty is not suddenly going to get rich and the wrestling team may not go to the state finals, but it is a real ending and ultimately much more satisfying. It's what being human is all about.
Win Win opened yesterday in select theaters. Don't miss it when it comes to your town.